How the Pakistan army lost the plot

Through months of melodrama in Pakistan, many experts expected that the army may intervene again in the name of “saving” the people from an “incompetent and self-serving” political class. Some experts believed that the Pakistan army will avoid taking responsibility for a troubled economy and the evolving complexities of geopolitics. In reality, the army is facing the real prospect of losing its control as well as its sheen. It has cleverly used political and non-political actors to shift the focus to the failures of the Imran Khan government and has set the stage for months of political wrangling between the government and an ex-PM on the loose.

This provides it with time and space to try to regain control within and beyond Pakistan’s borders. The contours of the maneuvers are already visible – including the use of proxy violence in Af-Pak, the aggressive propping up of the Haqqani group against the Kandahar Taliban and shoring up anti-West and extremist rhetoric in Pakistan through political and social media proxies. These dangerous moves are likely to further destabilize Af-Pak and other regions, and ultimately could create a “compelling” case for outside intervention in Afghanistan. The two historical “compelling” situations — the entry of Soviet troops in 1979 and the 9/11 attacks in the US — led to decades of war and violence in Afghanistan and serious spillover effects on the world. The decades since 1979 also led to the creation of some anti-Pakistan groups and resulted in much violence against its people. But the army strengthened its place as an “indispensable player”.

Till date, the army has maintained “supreme” domestic and international standing on four grounds: The use of proxies such as Taliban to ensure that under its rule, Afghanistan could not be used against Pakistan; providing access to the Taliban to the world; Its ability to manage internal and external security in a neighborhood portrayed as hostile and functional cooperation with both the US and China, attracting resources and seat at the high table. The army has sold itself as the “savior and pride” of Pakistan and go-to institution for the outside world.

However, the Taliban take-over of Afghanistan on August 15, 2021, has shattered the army’s standing. The world no longer needs it to access the Taliban or Afghanistan. The Taliban has turned the table on the army by steadfastly supporting the Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan’s (TTP) attacks on Pakistan forces. The attacks picked up pace with the signing of the Doha Agreement in February 2020. Between 2020 and 2021, the number of alleged attacks by the TTP went up from about 180 to over 320 and the consequence of Pakistan forces from 400 to over 800. This year, TTP has claimed over 400 blame in over 150 attacks on the Pakistan army, paramilitary and police forces across the tribal belt, in Balochistan and key cities.

In the past, the army had managed to curb the TTP’s social media campaigns to hide its consequence. Now, the TTP backed by pro-TTP Taliban accounts are showingcasing the names and faces of those getting killed. The Baloch and other groups have also upped the ante and are drawing moral support from the TTP, which is portraying “Afghans, Pashtuns and Balochs” as victims of the army’s brutality and calling for the liberation of the Af-Pak border region. Pashtun anger at the forcible erection of a barrier along the Durand Line is leading to frequent skirmishes with Pakistan’s forces. Acutely aware of serious threats, for months, the army has been struggling to manage the security situation with “unannounced” operations. However, it seems to be failing. After years of blaming foreign agencies for propping up the TTP, it now has no excuse for its failures.

Relations with China, at least in public, remain steadfast. However, Chinese interests in Pakistan are now being targeted more often. The April 26 suicide attack by a Baloch woman on a Chinese team inside Karachi University is a big escalation, which is being hailed by the TTP.

Despite all the talk about counter-terrorism cooperation with the US, coupled with “deliberate bravado” delivered through then PM Khan, the US has not taken the bait. The phone call that the US president never made to the PM seemed to be a loud message to the army about it untrustworthiness. By getting the former PM to court Russia and raising the anti-US rhetoric, the army is trying to create space for some rapprochement with the US.

Fully aware of its own weaknesses in Afghanistan and the dominance of the Pakistan army along its most crucial border, the Taliban also seems to be deeply suspicious of the latter’s intentions. The army’s double dealings have not only hurt its credibility with the West but also with the Taliban, perhaps irreparably. So, while the TTP is keeping the army in check, the Taliban is trying its hand at governing Afghanistan and stitching some loose alliances with other nations.

The army has used its command and control over the Islamic State Khurasan Province (ISKP) to mount deadly attacks on civilians, especially the Shia/Hazara and Taliban leaders and fighters in Afghanistan. In addition, it has been frequently attacking areas across the Durand line, inviting serious backlash from the Taliban-TTP combine as well as Pashtun populations. In a change of tactics, in the past few weeks, apart from Kabul, the ISKP is focusing on targets across non-Pashtun areas of northern Afghanistan. This would help divert the Taliban’s energies to the north and move the conflict closer to Central Asia and Iran. On April 18, the ISKP claimed to have fired a barrage of rockets towards Uzbekistan, which managed well the threats of the “real Daesh”, even through the heydays of the Caliphate. While attempts would be made to somehow break Taliban-TTP links, serious efforts are also visible in South Asia, including in Bangladesh and India, especially in Jammu & Kashmir. The latest propaganda of the ISKP and the other Pakistan proxy, al Qaeda in the Indian Subcontinent (AQIS), is just one indicator of threats building up to “reverse stretch” the neighbors, while the army tries to regain its control and sheen.

The writer is an IPS officer. Views are personal

.

Leave a Comment